Labor Enforcement in US–Mexico Trade: Inside and Outside the USMCA

In September 2026, the United States Trade Representative (USTR) found “sufficient” and “credible evidence” that supports an alleged denial of labor rights in relation to freedom of association and collective bargaining by Yokohama Tire Manufacturing Mexico, S.A. de C.V., located in Saltillo, in the state of Coahuila, Mexico. The Mexican labor union (Liga Sindical Obrera Mexicana) and the International Lawyers Assisting Workers Network (ILAW) filed the petition to investigate this alleged denial of worker rights. As a result, the USTR requested the Mexican Government to review whether the denial of rights exists. 

These actions are possible under the United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement (USMCA) framework. The USMCA created a level of labor-rights protection that was not present in the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). In fact, the Department of Labor (DOL) states that the Rapid Response Labor Mechanism (RRM) is “reversing the race to the bottom” in the US-Mexico trade relationship. Labor is on the agenda of the current USMCA review. 

Three specific labor rights enforcement mechanisms affect the US-Mexico trade relationship: two within the USMCA (Chapter 23 and RRM) and one outside the USMCA (Section 301). As policymakers and stakeholders move forward with the current USMCA review process, it is important to understand how these mechanisms work and which targets and parties bear the costs of such policies.

A Brief Overview of Labor Provisions in NAFTA and USMCA 

Labor provisions in NAFTA were set out in the North American Agreement on Labor Cooperation (NAALC), which stated that the trade partners would promote 11 labor principles as guiding goals. NAALC principles promote labor rights related to freedom of association, the right to bargain collectively and to strike, and the prohibition of forced labor, among other principles. Under NAFTA, member countries must enforce their own labor laws, but the 11 principles were non-binding, and no case ever reached an arbitral panel or resulted in trade sanctions. Under NAFTA, only labor issues related to child labor, minimum wage, and occupational safety and health were eligible for an arbitral panel. In contrast, issues related to freedom of association and collective bargaining went through ministerial consultations.

USMCA differs significantly from NAFTA on labor rights by establishing binding obligations and specific complaint-handling mechanisms. The USMCA created a new facility-level labor enforcement mechanism specific to the trade relationship between the US and Mexico, the RRM. For labor rights complaints, the USMCA expands  NAFTA's  ministerial consultations by allowing  labor rights cases to move through a binding panel and by specifying obligations. Furthermore, the USMCA also includes a clause requiring Mexico to strengthen labor laws related to collective bargaining and the administration of labor justice, which led to the 2019 Mexican labor reform. USMCA Annex 23-A required Mexico to protect collective bargaining by establishing an independent entity to register worker unions and ensure democratic elections of union leaders and an independent labor court for labor disputes.

Under the USMCA, a party (i.e., a government) can file a complaint through the RRM for the denial of rights of free association and collective bargaining at a covered facility in a priority sector. In the agreement, a priority sector refers to “a sector that produces manufactured goods, supplies services, or involves mining”, and the determination of priority sectors will be reviewed every year. USMCA Annex 31-A sets out guidelines and mechanisms for dispute settlement through RRM, including the imposition of trade penalties and, for repeated offenses, denial of entry for products. Most RRM cases have been resolved through agreed remediation, and as of October 2026, no trade penalties have been imposed. The US has requested Mexico’s review in 51 cases under the RRM between May 2021 and October 2026. 

Bar graph showing RRM requests for Mexico's review by year and sector

The figure above presents RRM requests by sectors during those years. During this period, 59-percent of the cases refer to auto, auto-parts and tire facilities, 18-percent to plants in other manufacturing sectors, and 8-percent to food and beverage manufacturing. Thus, about 84-percent of RRM cases are in the manufacturing sector. The remaining cases are in the mining (8-percent) and service sectors (8-percent).

Labor and the Current USMCA Review

There are currently three specific mechanisms related to labor issues between the US and Mexico. Under the USMCA, as discussed before, Chapter 23 provides a framework for trade partners' obligations related to labor rights, and Annex 23-A sets specific requirements for Mexico’s collective bargaining reforms. Additionally, under the USMCA, Annex 31-A provides a facility-level dispute settlement mechanism for labor rights complaints related to collective bargaining in priority sectors.

A new action that affects the US-Mexico trade relationship, related to Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, allows the US to respond to other countries' trade practices. The US, for example, investigated trade partners for practices associated with importing goods made with forced labor. In July 2026, the US announced it would impose a 10-percent tariff on Mexico because it found that Mexico failed to effectively enforce its forced-labor import prohibition. According to the USTR, the USMCA was the first US trade agreement to prohibit the importation of forced-labor goods, which Mexico adopted to meet USMCA requirements. This tariff excludes USMCA-qualifying goods and Section 232 goods. Mexico’s Secretary of Economy Marcelo Ebrard said it is likely this tariff will not affect more than 80-percent of Mexico's exports to the US.

In the current environment, where USMCA was not renewed in its current form in July 2026 but remains fully in force, labor is on the agenda for USMCA annual review. When considering legislation and policies that regulate labor issues between the US and Mexico, evaluating who the target of such regulation is and who bears the cost is important. Chapter 23 governs trade policy among USMCA members, while Section 301 is a unilateral US trade policy. In contrast, the RRM provides a mechanism that targets single plants. When considering who bears the cost of such trade policies, under Chapter 23, the whole economy would hypothetically bear the cost if trade restrictions were imposed. Offending plants bear the cost of their violation under the RRM. Under Section 301, the cost is likely to be imposed on all exporters of non-exempt goods, regardless of whether they abide by the prohibition on forced labor. 

Currently, the USMCA has critical areas for review related to labor issues. There is an interest in revising the RRM because of its limitations. About 42,000 of more than 5 million manufacturing workers have benefited from the RRM, representing less than 1 percent of workers in this sector. Anner (2026) argues that undemocratic unions continue to manipulate and dominate the system in Mexico. The US Chamber of Commerce recently stated that the RRM process needs more transparency, as companies have scarce information and limited time to respond to labor-rights allegations under the RRM. The RRM in practice has worked asymmetrically, as all cases to date have involved plants located in Mexico. According to Mexico’s labor ministry contribution to the September 2026 annual government report, as reported by El Economista, the RRM will take priority in future negotiations, and Mexico will not accept changes to Chapter 23 unless it addresses the RRM's asymmetric structure .

At the macro level, other important labor issues remain up for negotiation in the USMCA's future rounds and beyond. The termination of all active cooperative agreements within the DOL’s Bureau of International Labor Affairs affected the resources available for Mexico-specific programs to monitor and promote the enforcement of labor rights. As noted by Claussen et al. (2026), Mexico's 2025-2026 government budget cuts are likely to negatively affect USMCA labor commitments. Labor issues in other sectors related to US-Mexico trade are relevant, especially in the agricultural sector. For example, the Mexican government now requires a new certificate to verify that avocado export shipments are backed by workers formally hired under the Mexican Social Security Institute. This certificate requirement entered into force on October 1, 2026, and it is expected to be extended to other agricultural products in the future. For future USMCA rounds between the US and Mexico, it will be important to see what analyses take place regarding who the targets are and who bears the costs of such changes in trade policy. 

The author thanks Jazmine Fajardo, MPP candidate at Pepperdine School of Public Policy, for research assistance.

Author